Makes about 1 1/2 cups

WHY THIS RECIPE WORKS: The first few attempts were missing something. After a bit more research, we found several versions of this dish that benefit from a small shot of pickle juice because of its vinegary, sour flavor. This recipe needs a lot of stirring before the mixture starts to resemble pimento cheese, but don’t give up if it’s looking dry; after some vigorous stirring, the cheese and liquid ingredients start to combine and smooth out. But don’t overmix and make it too smooth—those small, cheesy lumps are what gives pimento cheese its characteristic texture.